Arguments Supporting the Georgist Tax Shift

Proponents of Georgism, including classical economists–as compared to the modern neoclassical economist–argue that a Land Value Tax (LVT) paired with a citizens’ dividend offers unique economic and social benefits:

  • Alignment of Self-Interest: Georgists argue that because the supply of land is fixed, taxing its unimproved value does not discourage production or effort. Personal self-interest is protected because individuals keep the full value of their wages and capital investments, while public self-interest is served by returning community-created land value to the public.
  • Reduction of Deadweight Loss: Economists such as Milton Friedman and Joseph Stiglitz have noted that taxing land value is the least distortionary forms of taxation. Unlike income or corporate taxes, an LVT does not penalise work, innovation, or investment, which increases productive efficiency.
  • Discouraging Speculation: Supporters contend that capturing land rent removes the incentive to hold land idle for speculative gain. This encourages owners to develop land or sell it to someone who will, increasing housing supply and lowering the cost-of-living.
  • Inflation Dynamics: The Georgist perspective of replacing taxes on labour and consumption (like GST or income tax) with a tax on land rent reduces the cost of production and goods. Furthermore, because land prices are largely driven by credit and speculative expectations, taxing land rent curbs real estate bubbles without raising interest rates which act to penalise productivity.

WHY THE ALP IS ON THE NOSE

LABOR PARTY HISTORY (from the ALP website)

The Australian Labor Party is the oldest political party in Australia, and among the oldest continuous Labour parties in the world. It is the great ‘party of initiative’ in Australian life.

In 1904, Chris Watson became Australia’s first Labor Prime Minister, as well as the first national Labour head of government anywhere in the world, though his was a minority government that lasted for just four months. Watson was only 37 years old and remains the youngest Prime Minister in Australian political history. Watson was succeeded in the party leadership by Andrew Fisher, who was returned as Prime Minister in the 1910 federal election, leading Australia’s first elected federal majority government. In 1914, as Australia entered the First World War, Fisher and the Labor Party were again elected, this time with decisive majorities in both houses – another world-first for Labor.
Lasting reforms of this early period of Labor leadership include maternity allowance, the foundation of a Commonwealth Bank, workers’ compensation for Commonwealth workers, establishment of the principle of the minimum wage, and expansion of the age pension.

In 1929, just two weeks before the crash of the New York Stock Exchange, Labor swept to victory under the Party’s first Australian-born leader, James Scullin. Unfortunately, the Scullin Government’s legislative program – designed to alleviate the economic crisis that followed – was severely stymied by the Opposition-controlled Senate, who declined to prioritise the national interest ahead of other considerations.

From 1941-49, the Curtin and Chifley governments confidently steered Australia through most of the Second World War and the transition to peace. Under Curtin (1941-1945), Labor led Australia through the Pacific War years, which were instrumental in establishing the sturdy alliance with the United States that persists to this day. Another of Curtin’s legacies was the significant expansion of social services. Regarded as a strong and successful leader through a period of great conflict, Curtin led Labor to a landslide victory in the 1943 election but died in office in 1945 just before the end of the War. He was succeeded in office by Ben Chifley, who led Labor to re-election in 1946. Over the following four years, the Chifley Labor Government (1945-1949) instituted an ambitious program of social reforms and nation building, including expanding the welfare state and a large-scale immigration program.

Chifley’s ‘light on the hill’ speech, delivered at the NSW Labor Party conference in 1949, is held by many to exemplify an ethos at the heart of both the Party and the labour movement: “We have a great objective – the light on the hill – which we aim to reach by working for the betterment of mankind,” he said, adding that “[Labor would] bring something better to the people, better standards of living, greater happiness to the mass of the people.”

Labor was defeated that same year by Robert Menzies’ Liberal-National Coalition, and commenced a 23-year period in opposition, before Gough Whitlam led the Party to victory at the 1972 election, ushering in a great era of modernisation in Australian politics.

____________________________

It’s instructive that before Australia had corporate and personal income taxes, the 1910 majority Fisher labor government immediately instituted the federal land tax to put an end to the agglomeration of land that had occurred across the country. The federal land tax acted to break up massive land holdings and greatly assisted development of Australian cities and regions for the people. Where is mention of this key policy in the party’s abovementioned history? No longer proud of it? Gone!

Today, the federal Labor party and its ministers run for the hills at any mention of reintroducing the federal land tax abolished by the Menzies government in 1953.

If the ALP wants again to be relevant, it needs to study its roots and offer a genuine alternative to the conservative parties. In view of the looming financial collapse, brought about by impossibly escalating land prices, this has become especially appropriate.

“INSIDERS”

No, Greg Sheridan. Instead of Australia having a ‘debt’ clock like the USA, showing how much they owe by stupidly issuing government securities, let’s have a private debt clock, because that really matters.

After all, that’s what’s about to deliver us into a worldwide financial depression.