…. you’re very close, guys! Have a read of Progress & Poverty!
I just read John Passant‘s 2012 paper “A basic guide to taxing economic rent in Australia” again today.
It contains a lot of worthwhile discussion on a subject critical to economies repairing themselves from the vicissitudes of rent-seeking.
Given the topic, however, you’d expect in addition to Smith, Ricardo, Marx, Ken Henry, John Freebairn et al, Passant may at least have read a little Henry George.
He’s clearly never done so, otherwise he couldn’t possibly have included this risibly dismissive one-line reference to George:
“… the Henry George idea of land as the foundation for all wealth.”
I guess we all make mistakes – but that’s a clanger and a half!
Just one more example of the ongoing disinformation concerning George’s tightly argued case that economic rent must be taxed away to stop monopolies from developing, and for labour and capital to receive their rightful reward.
A good win by the Australian cricket team, especially our new Don Bradman and recent bad boy, Steve Smith; supported of course in this 4th test by some pretty good fast bowling: but not much else.
A striking ashes series in which Aussies have also to acknowledge the innings of English bad boy Ben Stokes in the 3rd test. It’ll be remembered for years, too.
Something about bad boys having to prove themselves?
Then there’s the other ‘ashes’ in which it’s pretty tough to engage people at all, because it’s not such good news as the result of the test cricket series is to Aussies. [Maybe to suffering Englishmen, then?]
I’m a slow bowler, coming in on the fast bowler’s run-up. You might say I’m the veteran of the team, coming in off the long run; that is, since the end of WWII: the beginning of Nikolai Kondratieff’s 4th Long Wave; the one K didn’t live to see.
Kondratieff didn’t claim to understand what fashioned his great cycle of approximately 60 years, in his time series analysis of 36 price studies from the US, UK, France and Germany.
Of course neoliberal economists will declaim the ‘K-wave’ cycle, because it exposes their absolute impotence and their often useless mathematical models – particularly as economic depressions define the period of each Long Wave.
This one’s unfortunately going to reduce world economies to ashes. Not everyone’s cup of tea for discussion or analysis, I guess. I suppose like all good grasshoppers we should remain positive, up and about, and happy – never like those crazily negative damn ants.
Otherwise, you don’t know what might happen!
Post WWII, the 4th K-wave built up nicely to its inflationary peak in 1971, since which time increasingly greater real estate bubbles–which Nikolai Kondratieff failed to see had developed each one of his Long Waves–have directed the world relentlessly towards yet another depressionary trough that I consider, beginning in 2008, will extend into the late 2020s – because tax regimes will continue to devastate productive activity as they reward tax evaders and rent-seekers via banking, real estate speculation and debt.
Heterodox economists, money and debt theorists, MMT-ers and UBI supporters, generally correct in their analyses, will at best be lukewarm to this remedy, whilst rent-seeking neolibs will resist it until the last man has been bowled out.
That’s why we mustn’t speak about this other ashes
Things that shouldn’t have been said:
Zimbabwe dictator Robert Mugabe died yesterday.
In 2011, late in his oppressive regime as leader of the nation, Mugabe argued that Zimbabwean miners should be paying 51% of their profits by way of rent to the nation. He was quite right.
However, 30 years earlier, he double-crossed his partner Joshua Nkomo and had 20,000 of Nkomo’s followers killed.
Key to Nkomo’s economic proposals was that the newly-freed nation must capture Zimbabwe’s land and mineral rents for the nation.
How ironic. Too late, Robert Mugabe.
It’s not uncommon that supporters of the constructively peaceful ideas of Henry George are overtaken by iron-fisted Marxists whom even Karl Marx himself would disavow.
So, household final consumption contributed a nearly-invisible 0.2% to Australian GDP in the June quarter? And Oz annual growth slumped to 1.4%, the worst it’s been since the GFC in 2009?
In terms of last year’s Kavanagh-Putland Index (shown in black above), the lack of good news is to be expected. The only issue now is whether the Morrison government’s tax cuts and stimulatory measures have been sufficient to allay the recession which usually ensues within 2 years of a 25% drop in the Index (shown in orange).
Put another way, will Treasurer Josh Frydenberg’s “goodies” match the more than $50 billion Wayne Swan spent in 2008-09 to successfully keep the property market “up there”, and to kick the property bubble can down along the road?
I don’t think so.
Because a great number of Australians are already maxed out on debt, and a declining wage share doesn’t help resolve their indebtedness to banks. Rather, it applies additional financial constraint.
But hasn’t the property market shown recent improvement?
Yes, it has. But that’s the worry. It doesn’t resolve the problem of Australia’s extraordinary level of private debt. Our incredibly high land prices and mortgage debt are the main reason business, especially retail business, is so sluggish: aggregate demand is low.
Maybe curiously to some, the only hope for economic recovery is for the heat to come out of the property market, not to be shunted back into it. We and our politicians need to learn that the profitability of Oz banks does not translate to the general welfare of “hardworking Australians”.
‘Frank’ Stilwell, Emeritus Professor of Political Economy at Sydney University, delivered a very entertaining and insightful Henry George Commemoration Address at the Kelvin Club in Melbourne last night.
Frank is a national treasure.